German Red Herring Salad (Roter Heringssalat)

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• Unique color and flavor: The red beets tint the dressing a lovely pinkish-red hue, while the creamy mix of sour cream, mayonnaise, and vinegar delivers a balanced sweet-tangy profile .
• Bright and hearty: The combination of apples, herring, and pickles provides a wonderful blend of sweet, savory, acidic, and crunchy textures .
• Quick to assemble, better with rest: Ready in about 15 minutes, but chilling it for at least an hour (or overnight) deepens the flavors beautifully .

Ingredients

(Tip: You’ll find the full list of ingredients and measurements in the recipe card below.)

• Pickled (soused) herring fillets (e.g., German Bismarck or Matjes), drained and diced
• Medium apples, cored and diced
• Cooked red beets, diced
• Yellow or red onion, finely diced
• German-style pickles, diced
• Creamy dressing: Pickle juice; sunflower oil; white wine vinegar; sea salt; sugar; German yellow mustard; sour cream; heavy whipping cream; German mayonnaise; chopped fresh dill
• For serving: Boiled potatoes, hard-boiled eggs, or crusty bread .

Directions

1. In a small bowl, whisk together the pickle juice, oil, vinegar, salt, sugar, and mustard until the mixture is emulsified and the sugar and salt are dissolved. Then stir in the sour cream, whipping cream, mayonnaise, and chopped dill for the creamy dressing.
2. Place the diced pickled herring, apple, beets, onions, and pickles in a large bowl .
3. Pour the dressing over the herring mixture and gently stir until evenly combined. Adjust texture if needed add more cream if too thick, or more sour cream/mayo to thicken .
4. Cover and refrigerate the salad for at least one to two hours (or ideally longer) before serving to allow flavors to meld .
5. Serve by spooning onto a plate with boiled potatoes, or topped with slices of hard-boiled egg, a sprig of dill, or spread on crusty bread for a hearty option .

Servings and Timing

• Servings: Makes approximately 4 servings as a side or main, more if offered as hors d’oeuvres .
• Timing:
  • Prep Time: ~15 minutes
  • Total Time: ~15 minutes plus chilling/resting time.

Storage/Reheating

• Storage: Keep refrigerated in an airtight container. The flavors continue to develop; the salad stays delicious for several days, though optimal freshness is within 1–2 days .
• Reheating: This is a cold salad serve straight from the fridge. Let it rest briefly at room temperature if very chilled for best flavor.

FAQs

1. Can I make this ahead?

Yes it’s best made ahead. Chilling for an hour or two improves the flavor, and overnight is even better .

2. What are good serving options?

Traditionally served with boiled potatoes, hard-boiled eggs, or spread on crusty bread .

3. What type of pickles should I use?

Use authentic German-style pickles. Their flavor profile is essential American pickles may alter the dish’s taste.

4. Can I include potatoes or eggs in the salad?

Yes some variations stir diced boiled potatoes or hard-boiled eggs directly into the salad instead of serving on the side.

5. Why does the dressing turn pink?

The red beets bleed their natural color into the creamy dressing, giving it a distinctive pink-red hue that defines this salad.

6. Is dill necessary?

Fresh chopped dill lends authentic herbal brightness, but if unavailable, parsley also works or you can omit it altogether .

7. Can I adjust the dressing consistency?

Yes for a thinner dressing, add a bit more whipping cream; for thicker, add more sour cream or mayonnaise .

8. When is this commonly served?

Often enjoyed cold during festive buffets, especially at Christmas, New Year’s Eve, or during Lent in German households .

9. Can I substitute ingredients for dietary needs?

You can swap mayonnaise for yogurt, or adjust vinegar types. Just be aware that changes will alter traditional flavor balance .

10. What if I don’t like pickled herring?

Herring has a strong flavor, but paired with apples, beets, and the creamy dressing, it blends into a balanced palate. Start with a small amount if unsure.

Conclusion

German Red Herring Salad (Roter Heringssalat) is a distinctive and festive salad bursting with tangy, creamy, sweet, and savory notes. Its vibrant hue and fresh flavors make it a standout on any buffet or dinner table. Though simple to prepare, the chill time is key letting the flavors meld fully ensures the most delicious result. Enjoy chilled, traditionally with potatoes, eggs, or fresh bread, and savor this taste of German heritage.

Print